[45], The New York Times then noted, "Automatic computerized traders on the stock market shut down as they detected the sharp rise in buying and selling". whistleblower@hbsslaw.com. ETFs are scaring regulators and investors: Here are the dangersreal and perceived", "How a Mystery Trader with an Algorithm May Have Caused the Flash Crash", "Proposed Rule: Regulation NMS; Release No. Navinder Sarao in London on 23 March 2016. [8][81][82] Procter & Gamble in particular dropped nearly 37% before rebounding, within minutes, back to near its original levels. [] [S]tatements from page 36 of Kirilenko's paper[5] cast serious doubt on the credibility of their analysis. He lived in a modest West London suburb, the son of immigrants. London: In the end, the Navinder Sarao story got the Hollywood ending it deserved. His trading habits eventually drew scrutiny from the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, earning him cautionary letters. Navinder Sarao didnt seem like the international criminal mastermind type. The five stocks were EOG Resources, Genuine Parts, Harley Davidson, Ryder System and Zimmer Holdings. [4], In May 2014, a CFTC report concluded that high-frequency traders "did not cause the Flash Crash, but contributed to it by demanding immediacy ahead of other market participants". 8-13, Spring 2011; Available at SSRN: Easley, David and Lopez de Prado, Marcos and O'Hara, Maureen, Flow Toxicity and Volatility in a High Frequency World. Gm_-LxmMOc9Mu7DosK55ho2hbTQ. Now 42, Navinder Sarao is a self-taught stock market trader who helped cause panic in US markets in 2010 from a bedroom in his parents' home in Hounslow, West London. Can Nigeria's election result be overturned? Navinder Singh Sarao, a 37-year-old Indian-origin futures trader could be extradited to the US to face trial for his role in the May . Navinder Singh Sarao hardly seemed like a man who would shake the world's nancial markets to their . S7-10-04", "CFTC Fines Algorithmic Trader $2.8 Million For Spoofing In The First Market Abuse Case Brought By Dodd-Frank Act, And Imposes Ban | Finance Magnates", "After Stocks Blow Fuse, Circuit Breakers? We use By the first weekend, regulators had discounted the possibility of trader error and focused on automated trades conducted on exchanges other than the NYSE. The combined selling pressure from the sell algorithm, HFTs, and other traders drove the price of the E-Mini S&P 500 down approximately 3% in just four minutes from the beginning of 2:41 p.m. through the end of 2:44 p.m. During this same time cross-market arbitrageurs who did buy the E-Mini S&P 500, simultaneously sold equivalent amounts in the equities markets, driving the price of SPY (an exchange-traded fund which represents the S&P 500 index) also down approximately 3%. The mystery over the May 6, 2010 Flash Crash took a turn on Tuesday when the Department of Justice said it arrested a little known U.K.-based trader, Navinder Singh Sarao of Sarao Futures, for . Will His AI Plans Be Any Different? Here's how you know The cheating has just become more sophisticated., The Dow Jones dramatic 9 percent dip on May 6, 2010. He graduated from Brunel University and took a job at Futex, a trading firm that allowed workers to trade with the firm's own . [11] These orders amounting to about "$200 million worth of bets that the market would fall" were "replaced or modified 19,000 times" before they were cancelled. He liked that he was getting one over on his opponents.. AFP. Navinder Sarao will be extremely relieved not be spending another day behind bars. ntk20211104532. It always posted sell orders above the market and waited for a buyer; it never crossed the bid/ask spread. The speed allowed (mostly) large, monied firms to beat others to a trade, thereby securing a better price. Sarao was released on bail, banned from trading and placed under the care of his father. The story of the British day trader charged with triggering a trillion-dollar flash crash that caused havoc on Wall Street in 2010 ended where it began on Tuesday with a judge sentencing him to one year of home incarceration at his parents house. Navinder Singh Sarao helped send Dow on the wild,1,000-point ride that the world came to know as the flash crash. When a market order is submitted for a stock, if available liquidity has already been taken out, the market order will seek the next available liquidity, regardless of price. I think justice was done because the message was out there that someone shouldnt be thinking about doing what Nav was doing, the author says. Liam Vaughan 2020-05-12 "[An] extraordinary tale"Wall Street Journal "Compelling [and] engaging"Financial Times . On April 21, 2015, almost five years after the incident, the US Department of Justice charged Navinder Singh Sarao, a British . Sharp movements in stock prices, which were frequent during the period from 2008 to the first half of 2010, were in a decline in the Chicago Board Options Exchange volatility index, the VIX, which fell to its lowest level in April 2011 since July 2007. A recess was called to discuss the situation and the judge was satisfied Sarao would only be allowed to leave the house in a handful of circumstances. The report says that this was an unusually large position and that the computer algorithm the trader used to trade the position was set to "target an execution rate set to 9% of the trading volume calculated over the previous minute, but without regard to price or time". [25] The Wall Street Journal quoted the joint report, "'HFTs [then] began to quickly buy and then resell contracts to each othergenerating a 'hot-potato' volume effect as the same positions were passed rapidly back and forth. He was ordered to pay $38.4 million to the CFTC and the Justice Department, which determined that, of the money he made by day trading, only $12.8 million came from cheating the market. Criminal Charges: On November 9, 2016, Navinder Singh Sarao, 41, of Hounslow, United Kingdom . Meghan Markle desperate to fix Prince Harry's coronavirus Canadian teacher with size-Z prosthetic breasts placed on paid leave, Buster Murdaugh got 'very drunk' with dad 2 months after mom, brother murdered: source, What's next for Buster Murdaugh after dad's murder conviction, life sentence, Prince Harry was scared to lose Meghan Markle after fight that led to therapy, Prince Harry says psychedelics are fundamental part of his life, Inside Scheana Shay, Raquel Leviss heated confrontation about Tom Sandoval affair, Memphis Grizzlies star Ja Morant allegedly flashes gun at a strip club, Tom Sandoval, Raquel Leviss planned to tell Ariana Madix about affair. He didnt communicate with anyone.. According to Bloomberg, the VPIN metric is the subject of a pending patent application filed by the paper's three authors, Maureen O'Hara and David Easley of Cornell University, and Marcos Lopez de Prado, of Tudor Investment Corporation.[60]. [4], The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) investigation concluded that Sarao "was at least significantly responsible for the order imbalances" in the derivatives market which affected stock markets and exacerbated the flash crash. Navinder Singh Sarao's parents' home in Hounslow, west London. There, hed start earning tens of millions trading e-mini futures, a contract that tracks the S&P 500. Benchmarks . Available at SSRN: Andersen, Torben G. and Bondarenko, Oleg, Reflecting on the VPIN Dispute. He has also forfeited about $7.6m (5.8m) in illegal gains. An official website of the United States government. [27] As computerized high-frequency traders exited the stock market, the resulting lack of liquidity "caused shares of some prominent companies like Procter & Gamble and Accenture to trade down as low as a penny or as high as $100,000". U.S. regulators estimated that Sarao reaped $879,018 in net profits from his trading on the day of the flash crash alone. Save. It was the start of a regular morning for Mr Nachhattar Singh Sarao, on April 21, 2015, a well-respected man in his late 60s, and a long term resident of Hounslow. NSE Gainer-Large Cap . [19] Others speculate that an intermarket sweep order may have played a role in triggering the crash.[20]. [5]:1, Stock indices, such as the S&P 500, Dow Jones Industrial Average and Nasdaq Composite, collapsed and rebounded very rapidly. [17]:171, At first, while the regulatory agencies and the United States Congress announced investigations into the crash,[18] no specific reason for the 600-point plunge was identified. 2023 BBC. They also show that 2010, while infamous for the flash crash, was not a year with an inordinate number of breakdowns in market quality. According to Schapiro:[85]. Vaughan says Saraos motivation had little to do with money, and refers again to it being like a game for him: He really just saw the dollar signs that were rising in his trading account as points. [43], A few hours after the release of the 104-page SEC/CFTC 2010 report, a number of critics stated that blaming a single order (from Waddell & Reed) for triggering the event was disingenuous. Several plausible theories were put forward to explain the plunge. Available at SSRN: Andersen, Torben G. and Bondarenko, Oleg, Assessing VPIN Measurement of Order Flow Toxicity via Perfect Trade Classification (May 10, 2013). Nifty 146.95. [5]:3 A CFTC 2014 report described it as one of the most turbulent periods in the history of financial markets. 'We're incredibly grateful', says Navinder Singh Sarao's lawyer, "We're incredibly grateful," Mr Sarao's attorney Roger Burlingame told the BBC. When he asked how, the classmate replied: Trading.. [ 4]:1 O S&P 500, Dow Jones Industrial Average e o Nasdaq . With a coronavirus lockdown shortly ensuing, Navinder's timing was impeccable! A list of 'winners' and 'losers' created by this arbitrary measure has never been made public. How bedroom trader Navinder Sarao made his first millions and kickstarted an odyssey that ended with historic market manipulation and a $1 trillion crash Navinder Singh Sarao made $70 million buying and selling futures from his suburban London bedroom before the FBI showed up to arrest him for helping cause a $1 trillion market crash. ", Autistic futures trader who triggered crash spared prison, U.S. The first circuit breakers were installed to only 5 of the S&P 500 companies on Friday, June 11, to experiment with the circuit breakers. The orders were then replaced or modified 19,000 . Add this topic to your myFT Digest for news straight to your inbox, Liam Vaughans account of maths prodigy Navinder Sarao is a cautionary tale on modern finance, Spoofing by Navinder Singh Sarao from London blamed for 2010 market chaos, Navinder Singh Saraos extraordinary co-operation cited ahead of sentencing, Briton in spoofing case co-operates with prosecutors in plea deal, Rather than relying on law, redesign market structure for machine-dominated trading, DoJ hails extradition and conviction of Briton in fight against market manipulation, British trader faces 22 charges, including wire fraud and commodities manipulation, Michael Coscia made illegal profits by flooding futures markets with small orders and cancelling them, Algorithms have been developed that can spot incidences of market manipulation, Judge Purdey rules that the traders alleged conduct could constitute a criminal offence in the UK and US, Proscutors allege trader contributed to the 2010 flash crash, UK court told that futures trader used Chicago market, Academic questions how one man could cause such severe market turmoil, Challenge to focus on claims of scapegoating and potential sentence of 380 years if convicted in US, ICAP, BGC, Tullett and GFI subpoenaed in new trading investigation, Sarao defence calls on top academic to bolster claim that cancelling orders was commonplace, Civil charges levelled against Chicago-based proprietary trading firm and co-founder Oystacher, Disruptive dealing can result in a severe penalty as regulators begin to catch up, Russian far-right fighter claims border stunt exposes Putins weakness, Something is boiling: Turkish football fans tackle Erdoan, Three-day weekends and more time for love: Chinas elite dream up policies for Xi, Germany and Italy stall EU ban on combustion engines, Feds Daly says US rates likely to be higher for longer, Saudi owner of Londons most expensive house sued over alleged unpaid private jet bills, Why the Jeffrey Epstein scandal continues to haunt JPMorgan and Barclays, US electric vehicle batteries poised for new lithium iron age. But US prosecutors had recommended against jail time. Investigation: Navinder Singh Sarao, 36. [43] After a short while, as market participants had "time to react and verify the integrity of their data and systems, buy-side and sell-side interest returned and an orderly price discovery process began to function", and by 3:00 p.m., most stocks "had reverted back to trading at prices reflecting true consensus values". ", "Trades Dumped on Exchanges Blamed for Intensifying May 6 Crash", http://investor.cmegroup.com/investor-relations/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=513388, http://www.nanex.net/FlashCrashFinal/FlashCrashAnalysis_WR_Update.html, "Spontaneous recovery in dynamical networks", http://www.nature.com/nphys/journal/v10/n1/extref/nphys2819-s1.pdf, "Navinder Singh Sarao: The 'flash crash' trader who fell foul of Washington", "Autistic futures trader who triggered crash spared prison", "The trader blamed for the 'flash crash' tried to blow the whistle on other traders", "UK speed trader arrested over role in 2010 'flash crash', "Futures Trader Charged with Illegally Manipulating Stock Market, Contributing to the May 2010 Market 'Flash Crash', "British Trader Charged in 'Flash Crash' Released After Bail Reduction", "Documents show flash crash trader's frenetic business dealings", "Navinder Singh Sarao: reclusive trader or criminal mastermind? analyse how our Sites are used. He pedaled a bike around his suburban London neighborhood and would show up to important meetings munching on a McDonalds Filet-O-Fish. 1 reference. 23 April 2015. CFTC Chair Gensler specifically blamed the delay on the enormous effort to collect and analyze data. Officials announced that new trading curbs, also known as circuit breakers, would be tested during a six-month trial period ending on December 10, 2010. Like the SEC/CFTC report described earlier, the authors call this cascade of selling "hot potato trading",[53] as high-frequency firms rapidly acquired and then liquidated positions among themselves at steadily declining prices. DOJ cited extraordinary cooperation and autism diagnosis, British trader to be sentenced in Chicago on January 28. articles a month for anyone to read, even non-subscribers! In federal court in Chicago, Judge Virginia Kendall sentenced Mr Sarao to one year of supervised release with strict conditions, which limit his activities outside the home, according to a Bloomberg reporter who was in the courtroom. A U.S. judge on Tuesday, Jan. 28, 2020, sentenced Navinder Singh Sarao, a socially awkward math whiz-turned-futures trader who helped trigger a U.S. stock market "flash crash" from his parents' suburban London home to time served and a year's home confinement, sparing him imprisonment after prosecutors praised his cooperation and said his . The Journal of Trading, Vol. O ndice DJIA em 6 de maio de 2010 (11:00 - 16:00 EST) O Flash Crash de 2010, [ 1][ 2] conhecido simplesmente como Flash Crash[ 3] foi uma quebra trilionria nas bolsas de valores norte-americanas que teve incio s 14h32 EDT e durou aproximadamente 36 minutos. Google Knowledge Graph ID. As prices in the futures market fell, there was a spillover into the equities markets. Navinder Sarao in London in 2016. The sentencing of London's 41-year-old Navinder Sarao caps one of the more remarkable financial stories in recent memory. As noted below, we are reviewing the practice of displaying stub quotes that are never intended to be executed. The Chicago Board Options Exchange, NASDAQ, NASDAQ OMX BX and BATS Exchange all declared self-help against NYSE Arca. '"[25] The combined sales by the large seller and high-frequency firms quickly drove "the E-Mini price down 3% in just four minutes".[25]. They said the judge should consider his "extraordinary cooperation" with the government and diagnosis with autism. The orders amounted to about $200 million worth of bets that the market . The self-taught UK trader who made millions in bogus trades and contributed to a brief 2010 crash in the US stock market has been sentenced to a year of home . Navinder Singh Sarao faces extradition to the US over claims he caused an $800bn (565bn) "flash crash" in the US stock market from his parents' house in west London. However, independent studies published in 2013 strongly disputed the claim that one hour before its collapse in 2010, the stock market registered the highest reading of "toxic order imbalance" in previous history. [80] While stock markets do crash, immediate rebounds are unprecedented. Hounslow in west London, from where US authorities allege Navinder Sarao caused the market to crash, Analysis by BBC Business reporter Ramzan Karmali, according to a Bloomberg reporter who was in the courtroom, Navinder Sarao: The man accused of causing the US market to crash, Harry: I always felt different to rest of family, US-made cheese can be called 'gruyere' - court, The children left behind in Cuba's exodus, AOC under investigation for Met Gala dress, Canadian grandma helps police snag phone scammer. [12], On May 6, 2010, U.S. stock markets opened and the Dow was down, and trended that way for most of the day on worries about the debt crisis in Greece. Three erroneous NYSE Arca trades were said to have been the cause of the share price jump. Navinder Singh Sarao at his peak had a net worth of $70 million but is currently worth 1,000. In that short period of time, sell-side pressure in the E-Mini was partly alleviated and buy-side interest increased. Sarao was later arrested and extradited to the United States, only the second person ever charged with spoofing. Mr Sarao saw his trades as a way to "fight fire with fire", Mr Burlingame added. Navinder Singh Sarao. The DoJ alleged that Sarao earned more than 45m ($70m) in trading profits from his scheme of which at least $12.8m was attributable to his fraud and spoofing scheme. A better measure of the inadequacy of the current mlange of IT antiquities is that the SEC/CFTC report on the May 6 crash was released on September 30, 2010. Activities such as spoofing, layering and front running were banned by 2015. [52] The authors of this 2011 paper apply widely accepted market microstructure models to understand the behavior of prices in the minutes and hours prior to the crash. Harrods chief shrugs off recession fears because rich get richer, FCA regulator blamed for Arms decision to shun London listing, Argentina diary: Come armed with $100 bills, There are no domestic equity investors: why companies are fleeing Londons stock market, Clutching Warrens letter, Im still positive on stocks, The Murdaugh trial: a southern gothic tale that gripped the nation, Humanity is sleepwalking into a neurotech disaster, Who to fire? Phone. The Dow lost 9percent in a few minutes and most other indices took a historic hit before rebounding around a half-hour later. Navinder Singh Sarao was born in Hounslow, west London, in 1979. [] It is widely believed that the "sell program" refers to the algo selling the W&R contracts. The self-taught UK trader who made millions in bogus trades and contributed to a brief 2010 crash in the US stock market has been sentenced to a year of home confinement. his face inches from his screens, in what appeared to be a catatonic state, Vaughan writes. Navinder Singh Sarao" 22 . What had they just witnessed? Its unclear how much his actions contributed to Americas so-called flash crash. The US government contends that he was partially responsible, while some financial experts disagree, seeing him as a Robin Hood whose actions only hurt wealthy companies. Trading activities declined throughout 2011, with April's daily average of 5.8 billion shares marking the lowest month since May 2008. At 2:42 p.m., with the Dow down more than 300 points for the day, the equity market began to fall rapidly, dropping an additional 600 points in 5 minutes for a loss of nearly 1,000 points for the day by 2:47 p.m. Twenty minutes later, by 3:07 p.m., the market had regained most of the 600-point drop. [25] High-frequency firms during the crisis, like other firms, were net sellers, contributing to the crash. The Dow Jones Industrial Average on May 6, 2010 Source-Wikipedia. The idea that a guy in . US authorities say Mr Sarao made more than $70m between 2009 and 2014 trading from his childhood bedroom, including $12.8m tied to his illegal behaviour. Navinder Sarao, who traded from a bedroom in his parents west London home, was arrested in 2015 and pleaded guilty to illegally manipulating the stock markets with trades that led to one of the most dramatic crashes in history. Journal of Financial Markets, forthcoming. The May 6, 2010 flash crash,[1][2][3] also known as the crash of 2:45 or simply the flash crash, was a United States trillion-dollar[4] flash crash (a type of stock market crash) which started at 2:32 p.m. EDT and lasted for approximately 36 minutes. 0 references. In 2011 high-frequency trading firms became increasingly active in markets like futures and currencies, where volatility remains high. The drop quickly rippled into other financial markets in the United States but also around the world. Among the charges included was the use of spoofing algorithms; just prior to the flash crash, he placed orders for thousands of E-mini S&P 500 stock index futures contracts which he planned on cancelling later. [91] Former Delaware senator Edward E. Kaufman and Michigan senator Carl Levin published a 2011 op-ed in The New York Times a year after the Flash Crash, sharply critical of what they perceived to be the SEC's apparent lack of action to prevent a recurrence. When trading resumed at 2:45:33 p.m., prices stabilized and shortly thereafter, the E-Mini began to recover, followed by the SPY". The flash crash exposed this phantom liquidity. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. ""201056229. The sentence that was immediately thrown into doubt after lawyers said it would be unenforceable outside the US. The deception allowed Sarao to nudge the market higher or lower and reap the benefits. with somewhere in the region of $200bn worth of trades each day. 200.45. . However, the growth of computerized and high-frequency trading in commodities and currencies coincided with a series of "flash crashes" in those markets. Stocks continued to rebound in the following days, helped by a bailout package in Europe to help save the euro. I was just shocked at every turn, he adds. Was The Market Mayhem A Mistake? Wearing leg irons and an orange prison jumpsuit in a Chicago federal court, Sarao was freed on bail pending final sentencing, which occurs today, January 28, 2020. When a market order is seeking liquidity and the only liquidity available is a penny-priced stub quote, the market order, by its terms, will execute against the stub quote. From in or about June 2009 through in or about April 2014, in Chicago, in the Northern Navinder SINGH SARAO. Bloomberg via Getty Images. Instead of greed, the trader seems to have been motivated by viewing trading through the prism of his autism, which was described as both a disability and a talent. But in 2015, the online futures trader whod earned tens of millions of dollars from his bedroom was arrested and accused of contributing to a troubling 2010 market crash that momentarily wiped out trillions of dollars. US prosecutors as well as his own legal team had called for leniency. File photo of Navinder Sarao arriving at Westminster Magistrates' Court for an extradition hearing in London (Reuters) - A Chicago-based U.S. federal district court judge on Tuesday sentenced Navinder Sarao, a London-based trader accused of contributing to Wall Street's 2010 "flash crash", to time already served in jail of four months, with a . A minute later, markets tumbled with a velocity and intensity it never had before, Vaughan writes. Navinder Singh Sarao made $70 million buying and selling futures from his suburban London bedroom before the FBI showed up to arrest him for helping cause a $1 trillion market crash. Still lacking sufficient demand from fundamental buyers or cross-market arbitrageurs, HFTs began to quickly buy and then resell contracts to each othergenerating a hot-potato volume effect as the same positions were rapidly passed back and forth. Even as a young boy, he had a photographic memory and was a whiz with numbers. By Monday, June 14, 44 had them. Updated: April 23, 2015 6:31 pm IST. Navinder Singh Sarao Spoofing. [89], On May 6, the markets only broke trades that were more than 60 percent away from the reference price in a process that was not transparent to market participants. Liam Vaughan's account of maths prodigy Navinder Sarao is a cautionary tale on modern finance. 206-623-7292. ", "Flash crash trader Navinder Singh Sarao bailed after declaring 25.5m in Swiss account", "The flash crash trader Navinder Singh Sarao returns to London cell ahead of extradition fight", "Lotfi Raissi case: How false link to al-Qaida kept innocent Algerian in jail", "How the Flash Crash Trader's $50 Million Fortune Vanished", "Hound of Hounslow: Who is Navinder Sarao, the 'flash crash trader'? [55], Note that the source of increasing "order flow toxicity" on May 6, 2010, is not determined in Easley, Lopez de Prado, and O'Hara's 2011 publication. Friday 05 June 2020 1:21 pm . As of July 2011, only one theory on the causes of the flash crash was published by a Journal Citation Reports indexed, peer-reviewed scientific journal. Navinder Sarao didn't . Additionally, the most precipitous period of market decline in the E-Mini S&P 500 futures on May 6 occurred during the 3 minute period immediately preceding the market bottom that was established at 13:45:28. [15]:641 The Reg NMS, promulgated and described by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, was intended to assure that investors received the best price executions for their orders by encouraging competition in the marketplace, created attractive new opportunities for high-frequency-traders. Navinder Singh Sarao is a London-based trader who was arrested on April 21, 2015 on charges his firm, Nav Sarao Futures Limited PLC, contributed to the May 2010 "Flash Crash" in which the Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 600 points in five minutes.UK authorities charged him with wire fraud, manipulation and commodities fraud, using illegal trading strategies such as spoofing. [43], The joint 2010 report "portrayed a market so fragmented and fragile that a single large trade could send stocks into a sudden spiral",[25] and detailed how a large mutual fund firm selling an unusually large number of E-Mini S&P contracts first exhausted available buyers, and then how high-frequency traders (HFT) started aggressively selling, accelerating the effect of the mutual fund's selling and contributing to the sharp price declines that day. [10], On April 21, 2015, nearly five years after the incident, the U.S. Department of Justice laid "22 criminal counts, including fraud and market manipulation"[11] against Navinder Singh Sarao, a British Indian financial trader. Mr Burlingame said Judge Kendall had considered Mr Sarao's crimes in the "proper context", which had included complaining to market officials about spoofing by other traders. Navinder "Nav" Sarao, an "insomniac" who said traded S&P futures using the click of a mouse, . On Tuesday a Chicago court sentenced him to one year of home incarceration, returning him to the childhood home in Hounslow where the crimes were committed and where he still lives with his parents. A British trader who was accused of helping to cause the 2010 Flash Crash, which temporarily cut $1 trillion in stock market value, was sentenced in the US on Tuesday to one year of home incarceration in his parent's house. The defendant has since surrendered his only remaining trading profits approximately $7.6m (which the defendant has represented to be and the government believes to be his only liquid assets) to the United States in partial satisfaction of the $12.8m forfeiture order in this case.. The combined average daily trading volume in the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq Stock Market in the first four months of 2011 fell 15% from 2010, to an average of 6.3 billion shares a day. His only big purchase was a secondhand Volkswagen Golf. [2] NASDAQ's timeline indicates that NYSE Arca may have played an early role and that the Chicago Board Options Exchange sent a message saying that NYSE Arca was "out of NBBO" (National best bid and offer).